STRUGGLING IN SILOS: FROM CLASSROOM TO COURTROOM

By: MUHAMMAD ZAMAN BUTT
Advocate High Court.
12 October, 2025

Introduction

Fresh advocates enter courts and meet harsh realities. Competition stays intense. Laws keep changing. Procedures demand precision. Many graduates lack hands-on training, so they struggle to plead before the bench. I lay out practical fixes that connect classrooms with courtrooms and help young lawyers build real competence fast.


The First Wall: Competition and Readiness

Law schools produce large cohorts every year. Firms and clients choose only a few. New lawyers must learn court craft, filing protocols, case strategy, and client handling on day one. Without clinical exposure, they fall behind. The profession rewards speed, accuracy, and advocacy skills; theory alone does not deliver these outcomes.


Fix the Pipeline: Skills-First Curriculum

Law schools must center learning around practice. Build core modules that teach:

  • Legal research that answers a judge’s question

  • Structured drafting: petitions, pleadings, opinions, and contracts

  • Oral advocacy: case theory, openings, and structured submissions

  • Ethics and client care: confidentiality, conflicts, and billing basics

Integrate moots, mock trials, and clinics into required credits. Tie grades to demonstrable outputs: written drafts, oral arguments, and file management checklists.


Bring the Profession Inside the Classroom

Universities must partner with law firms, legal aid clinics, bar associations, and courts. Create semester-long placements with defined learning goals. Supervisors must review logs, give written feedback, and sign off only when students meet performance rubrics. Students then graduate with evidence of competence, not just attendance.


Empower Faculty to Teach Practice

Faculty need incentives and tools. Schools should:

  • Recruit seasoned litigators to co-teach advocacy studios

  • Fund pedagogy training that supports experiential learning

  • Reward course designs that include simulations and live matters

Teachers who practice current procedure can coach students to draft better and argue smarter.


Build Accountability That Measures What Matters

Schools must track practical outcomes. Use simple, transparent metrics:

  • Number of supervised drafts per student

  • Average rubric score on oral submissions

  • Placement hours and verified feedback from supervisors

  • Bar and early-career milestones (first filing, first argument)

Publish aggregate dashboards each term. When administrators see real numbers, they can fix bottlenecks fast.


What Students Can Do Today

Students do not need to wait. They can:

  • Secure internships with clear tasks: drafting, research, and court visits

  • Enter moot and mock trial teams that simulate real pressure

  • Maintain a portfolio: sample petitions, research memos, and argument outlines

  • Take short courses on evidence, advocacy, and drafting

  • Volunteer with clinics to meet clients and see justice issues firsthand

Proactive learners compound skills faster than peers who rely on lectures alone.


Close the Gap: Turn Theory into Courtroom Wins

Students must test classroom rules in live contexts. Read a statute, then draft an application that uses it. Study a precedent, then frame an argument that distinguishes or follows it. Court exposure teaches cadence, etiquette, and timing—skills that books cannot transfer.


Network With Intention

Networking shapes opportunity. Young lawyers should:

  • Attend bar events and CPD sessions with a goal and a notebook

  • Ask seniors for shadow days in chambers and courtrooms

  • Join practice-area groups and contribute short case notes

  • Follow up with value: a summary of a new judgment or a clean draft template

Real relationships grow when you help first.


A Compact for Change: Institutions and Students

Institutions must modernize curricula, formalize mentorships, and expand clinic seats. Students must chase practical work, build portfolios, and give feedback that improves courses. When both sides move together, graduates enter court with confidence and clients gain better service.


Actionable Recommendations

For Law Schools

  • Make clinics and moots credit-bearing and mandatory

  • Sign MOUs with firms, legal aid bodies, and courts for supervised placements

  • Adopt skills rubrics and publish termly outcome dashboards

  • Reward faculty who deliver experiential, assessment-driven courses

For Students

  • Target internships with weekly deliverables and supervisor reviews

  • Build a public-safe portfolio that showcases drafting and argument skills

  • Track learning goals: filings observed, arguments delivered, drafts completed

  • Seek mentors and schedule structured check-ins

For the Bar and Bench

  • Offer chambers placements and feedback hours for juniors

  • Host open court orientation sessions on practice and procedure

  • Share anonymized model drafts and checklists that set quality bars


Conclusion

Fresh advocates can thrive when schools teach practice, mentors open doors, and students pursue deliberate training. Replace silos with partnerships. Replace theory-heavy courses with outcomes-driven studios. When everyone commits to skill, clients receive better advocacy and the justice system works better for all.